The 2am Email That Changed Everything
Sarah runs a boutique marketing agency. Last Tuesday at 2am, she got an email from a potential client—one that made her heart sink.
*”Hi Sarah, I’ve been trying to contact you through your website for three days. Your form keeps giving me an error. I’ve decided to go with another agency. Just thought you should know.”*
Three days. Three days of a broken contact form, and she had no idea.
The worst part? This wasn’t an isolated incident. When Sarah finally checked her server logs, she discovered her form had been broken for almost two weeks. She’ll never know how many potential clients gave up and moved on.
The Invisible Problem
Here’s the thing about broken WordPress forms: they fail silently. Your site looks fine. Your pages load. Everything *appears* normal. But underneath, something’s broken, and you won’t know until someone tells you—or worse, until they don’t.
Common culprits include:
– Plugin updates that break compatibility
– PHP version changes on your hosting server
– Conflicts between your form plugin and security plugins
– Email delivery issues that you can’t see from the frontend
– Spam protection that’s accidentally blocking real submissions
Why This Happens More Often Than You Think
WordPress plugins are updated constantly. Your contact form plugin might get updated to version 5.2, which works great—except it doesn’t play nice with your caching plugin anymore. Or your hosting company upgrades PHP, and suddenly your form submission handler breaks.
These aren’t hypothetical scenarios. We see this happen all the time.
Last month, we caught a broken form on a client’s site within two hours of it breaking. The culprit? A routine security plugin update that changed how forms are validated. The client never would have known until someone complained—or until they noticed leads mysteriously drying up.
The Real Cost
Let’s do some quick math. If your website generates even one qualified lead per week worth $2,000 in revenue, a broken form for two weeks costs you roughly $4,000 in lost opportunity. And that’s being conservative.
For e-commerce sites, the numbers get even scarier. A broken checkout form could cost thousands per day.
But beyond the immediate revenue loss, there’s the reputational damage. When someone can’t contact you through your website, what message does that send? “We’re not professional enough to maintain our own site” isn’t exactly the first impression you want to make.
How to Catch These Issues Early
The good news is that broken forms are entirely preventable with the right monitoring:
1. Regular Testing
Someone needs to actually submit test forms regularly. Not once a month—weekly at minimum. This sounds obvious, but most business owners only discover issues when a customer reports them.
2. Post-Update Checks
Every time a plugin updates (which can be multiple times per week), someone should verify that forms still work. Again, this sounds simple, but it requires discipline and time most business owners don’t have.
3. Monitor Email Deliverability
Just because the form submitted doesn’t mean you received the email. Email deliverability is a whole separate issue that needs monitoring.
4. Check Error Logs
Your WordPress site keeps error logs. Most people never look at them. These logs will tell you when forms are breaking, often before users start complaining.
The Bottom Line
Your contact form is often the most important element on your website. It’s the bridge between interest and action, between a visitor and a customer.
Treating form maintenance as an afterthought is like leaving money on the table. Worse, it’s like actively turning customers away at the door.
At WP Contained, form monitoring is built into our weekly checks. We submit test forms, verify email delivery, and check for errors after every update. It’s not glamorous work, but it’s the kind of unglamorous work that keeps businesses running.
Because the only thing worse than a broken form is not knowing it’s broken until it’s too late.
—
Pro Tip: Set up a separate email address just for form testing (like forms-test@yourdomain.com). Submit a test every Monday morning before the work week begins. It takes 30 seconds and could save you thousands in lost leads.
—